Advanced device relaxation

In this tutorial you will learn how to use a combination of “Rigid” constraints and a simple optimization routine to perform efficient and reliable relaxation of the internal coordinates in a device configuration.

intro

Introduction

Relaxation of the internal coordinates of device configurations can be a tedious and time consuming task. There are two main reasons for this:

The 2-probe configuration consists of three distinct regions: Two electrodes and a central region consisting of electrode extensions and a scattering region. The geometry of each region should be separately optimized in a first-principles manner, but both electrode extensions in the central region must always match the corresponding electrode.

Step 1: Optimize the electrodes. After optimization of the electrodes, it is important to make sure that the electrode extensions in the central region match the optimized electrodes.

Step 2: Optimize the central region. The optimum length of the central region is usually not known a priori. In the case of a periodic bulk, one would minimize the stress tensor. However, the stress field is not uniquely defined for a device configuration, so another approach is needed.

In the second step, we must rely on minimizing the device total energy while explicitly preserving the internal coordinates of the electrode extensions. There are at least two different ways to do this using VNL and ATK.

BRR method

After building the 2-probe configuration from fully relaxed electrodes, you extract the central region bulk and relax it with “Rigid” constraints on the atoms belonging to the electrode extensions. The device or interface is then reassembled from the relaxed bulk. This is a computationally efficient approach and will usually capture a large fraction of the required geometry relaxation. We shall refer to this method as Bulk Rigid Relaxation (BRR).

The BBR method does not calculate the total energy using a full device geometry, so the reassembled device may not be exactly in the global minimum-energy geometry. Some types of electronic structure calculations may be sensitive to this difference, others may not.

1D minimization

A somewhat more brute-force approach is to explicitly minimize the device total energy wrt. internal coordinates and the central region length, i.e., do the full 2-probe calculations and vary the central region length. This is a 1D minimization problem with relaxation of the atomic positions at each step, so we shall refer to this method as 1DMIN. We have developed a procedure for doing this as efficiently as possible with ATK, but the computations are in general more demanding than with BRR. It is therefore recommended to use 1DMIN only after pre-relaxing the central region with the BRR method.

This tutorial introduces the electrode relaxation and the central region relaxation using BRR and 1DMIN methods. The methods are illustrated for relaxing a silver-gold interface using a classical potential. The classical potential is selected for computational convenience, and the same procedure could be used for another relaxation method like DFT. In general we recommend to check ATK-ForceField calculations with DFT calculations.

Tip

We have prepared a graphical explanation of the steps outlined above. You can see and download the infographic of the present tutorial at the Infographics paragraph.

Preparations

First make a new project called ‘device_relaxation’. Our starting point is an unrelaxed 2-probe device configuration. It was created using the VNL Interface Builder follow the tutorial at this link: Building an interface between Ag(100) and Au(111). The geometry can also be downloaded as this file: Ag_Au_interface.py.

Save the py-file in your project folder, locate the device configuration on the LabFloor, and drag-and-drop the configuration to the builder_icon Builder.

The 2-probe configuration should look like the one illustrated below. It consists of a left electrode, Ag(100), the central region, and a right electrode Au(111). Use the SplitDevice01_icon plugin to split the device into a left electrode, right electrode and central region.

snap1

Electrode relaxation

The device geometry was constructed using the interface builder (Building an interface between Ag(100) and Au(111)). Prior to building the interface the left and right crystal structures were set up using their experimental geometries. We will assume that the experimental geometry is also the lowest energy structure of the theoretical method we will use for relaxing the device geometry.

In the interface builder we choose “Strain second surface” upon selecting the surface cell. This means that the Ag(100) surface was kept in its experimental geometry, while the Au(111) surface was strained in the x,y directions upon forming the interface. When the crystal is strained in the x,y directions, it will relax in the z-direction according to the Poisson ratio of the material.

In the following we will apply this relaxation to the Au(111) crystal, by relaxing the stress in the z-direction while keeping the x, y directions fixed. The obtained relaxation of Au(111) will be transferred to the gold atoms in the central region.

Open the builder and change the name of the right electrode to Au111. Double click the geometry to make it active and send it to the script_generator_icon Scripter. Add the following objects:

  • calculator_icon New Calculator
  • optimization_icon OptimizeGeometry

snap2

Now open the New Calculator object and select the ATK-ForceField “EAM_Zhou_2004” potential. Click OK.

Note

For ATK-versions older than 2017, the ATK-ForceField calculator can be found under the name ATK-Classical.

Next open the Optimize Geometry object:

  1. Set the force tolerance to 0.01
  2. Set the stress tolerance to 0.001
  3. Uncheck z in the “Constrain cell” checkboxes

snap3

Send the script to the job_manager_icon Job Manager and run the relaxation. It should take less than a minute to execute. When finished inspect the log file.

You should now see a new object on the LabFloor called “Au111.nc”. It contains two configurations, corresponding to the geometry before and after the relaxation. Select the two geometries and drop them onto the viewer_icon Viewer. In the viewer you can hoover the mouse over the unit cell of each configuration and you will notice that the length of the C vector is 7.064 Å before the relaxation and 7.011 after the relaxation. This information could also be obtained from the log file, “Au111.log”.

The relaxation results in a small compressive strain of 0.75%. To apply this to the central region, open the Builder and double click the central region configuration.

  1. Rename the stash item to “central”.
  2. Select all the gold atoms by drawing a rectangle around them.
  3. Open the Bulk Tools ‣ Stretch Cell plugin.
  4. Enter 0.9925 along the C axis.
  5. Use “Selected atoms are” stretched.
  6. Click Apply.

snap4

Note

The strain is so tiny that it is not possible to see any visual change in the structure. However, you may open the “Lattice Parameters..” plugin and click the undo_edit_icon and redo_edit_icon buttons to see how the C cell vector changes when you undo and redo the stretch. Similarly, you can inspect the Coordinate List.

Central region relaxation

You are now going to relax the central region only. We want the electrode extensions to be able to move freely (but rigidly) during geometry relaxation. We therefore add vacuum on both ends:

Make sure that no atoms are selected, by clicking the background of the plotting window. In Bulk Tools ‣ Stretch Cell use the C-vector slider to increase the cell length by 30% or simply type in a multiplication factor of 1.3. The cell is stretched once you click Apply.

Move to Coordinate Tools ‣ Center and uncheck A and B. Center the central region by clicking Apply.

snap5

We want to fix the atoms in the electrode extensions by including an additional layer of the central region. The additional layer will help the Device from Bulk tool in VNL to identify the length of the electrode. For this purpose select the 5 outermost silver atoms. Open Selection Tools ‣ Tags. Enter Left in the box named “Click here to write a new tag...”. Press Return.

Next select the 4 outermost gold atoms, and tag them Right.

snap6

Send the configuration to the script_generator_icon Script Generator and set up the calculation:

Add a calculator_icon New Calculator and an optimization_icon OptimizeGeometry object.

Choose the ATK-ForceField engine and the “EAM_Zhou_2004” potential for these calculations.

Make the following changes to the OptimizeGeometry object:

  1. Set the force tolerance to 0.01 eV/Å.
  2. Check “Save trajectory” and set the filename to central.nc.
  3. Click “Add Constraints” to set up the Rigid constraints on the electrode extensions.
  4. Check that the Left and Right tags are assigned to the correct atoms in the configuration. Do this by clicking the tags. Choose “Rigid” constraints for both tags.
  5. Click OK and return to the Scripter.

snap7

Note

Choosing instead a “Fixed” constraint for one of the tagged regions while keeping the other one “Rigid”, may save BFGS relaxation steps and thereby computational time.

Send the script to the job_manager_icon Job Manager and run the calculation. It should be very fast. Once finished, the central.nc output file appears on the LabFloor.

You can use the viewer_icon Viewer plugin to see the trajectory of the relaxation as illustrated in the animation below.

snap8

The relaxed central region is saved in central.nc as the bulk configuration with id “glD002”. This is your initial guess for the central region geometry. Drag-and-dro it on to the builder_icon Builder.

Click Device Tools ‣ Device From Bulk to turn the central.nc bulk into a device configuration. You can leave the settings for electrode and central region lengths at default values.

The interface configuration should now look like illustrated below. Rename the configuration to “device” by using F2 or with a right mouse-click.

snap9

1DMIN optimization of the interface using 2-probe calculations

We are now ready to search for the global minimum-energy geometry of the Ag(100)-Au(111) interface. Save the device configuration as a NetCDF file named device_in.nc by choosing “Save as” after right-clicking the device Stash item.

snap10

You are now going to apply a simple SciPy minimization procedure in search for the central region length that minimizes the interface total energy. The device configuration you just saved in device_in.nc is the starting point for this.

Two scripts are needed. You can download them here: device.py and optimize.py. Save both scripts in the folder where device_in.nc was saved. The first script (device.py) reads in the device configuration and sets up and runs the calculation, while the second script (optimize.py) contains functions and classes used by device.py.

Note

To use the script device.py for other systems you need to edit the script and change the definition of the potential to an appropriate potential for your new system.

Both scripts should now be available in the VNL “Project Files” list. Drag-and-drop device.py onto Jobs. The job_manager_icon Job Manager will open. Click jm_play_enabled_icon to run the script.

Once finished (it’s fast!), a window with the figure below will pop up. The blue points are total energies of relaxed interface configurations. The initial cell length is 28.51 Å and the other blue points are trial guesses made by the algorithm. The red point indicates the optimum central region length which is 28.58 Å. The optimization routine simply maps out the illustrated potential-energy surface and finds its minimum!

snap11

The job will finish when you close the pop-up window.

The relaxed configurations are saved in the output file device_out.nc along with the total energies. The configuration corresponding to the red point (the final device or interface geometry) is the latest device configuration (the one with largest id number).

Using the viewer_icon Viewer plugin, the minimum-energy interface configuration looks like this:

snap12

In this case the change to the structure after the 1DMIN relaxation is minute compared to the BRR relaxation. Often the BRR will be sufficiently accurate and there is no need for the 1DMIN step. The 1DMIN approach is only needed for extreme accuracy.

Infographics

Download Infographics in pdf version. Click the button below to see the infographics.